Time and a Scooter

Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

She is blond and well tanned. Her spouse wears green trousers a matching polo shirt. They have been married for forty nine years, which explains some of their dynamics. The husband scoffs at his wife and rolls himself to the side of his chair, away from her. She conveys he has lost some memory. The wife knows the facts and conveys them easily without stammering. She answers many of the doctor’s questions, when she sees her spouse stuck on a syllable. Like the small steps the feet take, the person with PD may have problems articulating thoughts- both repeat a motion, though little change occurs.

The doctor asks about the schedule of medications, and the wife replies that her spouse may forget a dose when occupied, so the schedule is constantly changing, though he strives to take his pills every three hours. The doctor rips a page from the pad of paper on his desk and begins constructing a table that would make up a medication diary. He states he can be of little use unless he is aware of how the patient responds to his medication; how long it takes for the pills to take effect, whether he experiences dyskinesias, and when they occur. He asks the wife to attempt the diary for a period of two weeks, so that he can see where patterns emerge. Email it to me, he says. With that information they can modify the daily course of drugs.

She is pleased that the physician has discouraged the two doses of night- time medication. The doctor insists the patient must have six hours of sleep nightly, at least. To make this a possibility he recommends the drug Seroquel, to be taken in gradually increasing quantities until the patient finds he is sleeping through the entire night. An enlarged prostate means the man must rise to urinate several times in the night; Depends may be needed when the quality of sleep improves.

Diagnosed with the illness fifteen years ago, the gentleman underwent deep brain surgery a year and a half ago. The physician asks whether they have seen an improvement in symptoms, and the wife shakes her head, doubtful. Then she notes her spouse no longer has tremor at all. While he demonstrates his gait in the hallway outside the office, the patient’s arms swing freely. The arm swing, the wife notes is also much better, he used to carry his right arm next to his torso. He takes the same amount of dopamine replacement.

After the physical exam the wife mentions her spouse fell in a field and she was unable to help him to his feet. They had to wait for some time, until another person appeared to assist. She worries he will fall again and wonders whether the physician can help them acquire a motorized scooter. The doctor writes the couple a prescription for physical therapy, which is the agent that has the power to aid them. The patient comments to the physician he is unlike other doctors, he has given them some time.

Grandmother & Grand-daughter

Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

The patient arrives with her grand-daughter who reports she is the caretaker. Her grandmother speaks only Spanish and her hearing has deteriorated. At home she uses a walker to get through her house, outside she uses a four-pronged cane.

In 2007 she was told she had Parkinson’s disease, and received a prescription for Sinemet and Comtan. The physician asks whether she feels some improvement of her symptoms with the dosage she takes. The older woman is noncommittal. The dosage is quite low and she only takes it three times a day. The physician asks what her presenting symptoms were, that led her to seek a doctor, five years ago. She reports some tremor in her right hand, and that she had fallen twice; once in the bathroom, another time when getting from the bed.

The doctor enlightens the grand-daughter that few people who come to see him for the first time, when they are eighty-four truly have Parkinson’s disease. The illness is most often diagnosed when people hit their sixties, though it’s possible that someone who abhors the doctor might defer the first visit for a few years. If most people put off the visit until they were in their eighties, they would arrive in a stooped posture, a whispery voice, masked facial expression and all movements would be slow and rigid.

Her grandmother sits upright in the chair, with an expressive face and a natural quality to her speech. Testing her arms and wrists for rigidity, the doctor feels the muscles surrounding her joints are supple and loose. He tells the caregiver he thinks she suffers from lower-body parkinsonism; a type of illness brought on by microvascular disease caused by long-term hypertension. In patients with this sort of problem, they rarely see any affect from medication until the dosage is quite high. He begins making a schedule for increasing the dosage of Sinemet until she takes two and a half pills four times throughout the day. Increasing the dosage by half a pill, the schedule will take more than two months to complete. He also suggests the patient have an MRI of the brain, and prints out a prescription to have the test done. Encouraging the patient to exercise on a stationary bike may be tricky. She suffers from two degenerative disks in her lower spine and her left knee pains her constantly. The doctor feels she must continue to take the pain medications, though exercise may allay some discomfort and will help increase her general health.

With straight red hair, cut and curled at the ends, the grand-daughter straightens several locks of her hair, as they leave. She comments if her grandmother catches sight of herself in a mirror, she would be horrified and question why she let her be in public in such disarray, asking her aren’t you supposed to care for me?

The Doughnut Hole

Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

“After a Medicare beneficiary surpasses the prescription drug coverage limit, the beneficiary is financially responsible for the entire cost of prescription drugs until the expense reaches the catastrophic coverage threshold”.
From Wikipedia

At the monthly visit to the pharmacy my father got a bill for two hundred nine dollars for his Parkinson’s drugs. He was used to paying thirty dollars. He had fallen into the doughnut hole, the time where insurance no longer covers a fraction of the cost of medications. He believes the month is arriving earlier this year, which is possible as the cost of drugs only goes up, which makes arriving at the sum of $2,840, the amount spent by the patient plus the amount spent by the insurance company, occur prior to last year.

However, things could be worse. In 2010 the government sent $250 checks to seniors who had hit the doughnut hole during the 2010 calendar year. In 2011 when patients fall into the doughnut hole they will pay fifty percent of the retail cost of brand name medications. Though there is nothing to dissuade drug companies from jacking up their retail prices. Generic drugs receive a seven percent discount. I doubt my father knew he was actually getting a discount on his drugs.

There is also a program for those who need ‘full help’. Such programs offer smaller copayments for medicine and no doughnut holes. Those on limited incomes can receive ‘extra help’ from the government. Drug costs in 2011 for most people who qualify are about $2.50 for each generic and $6.30 for each brand-name. Qualified Medicare individual beneficiaries must have a monthly income of $923 or less. For a married couple the monthly income limit is $1,235.

Don’t most eighty year olds have limited incomes?

On the far side of the coverage gap, there is another shore. Your toes touch those sands when you have spent $4,550 of your cash. Your insurance retakes your hand, and you pay five percent of the retail cost of medication. The doughnut hole is slated to vanish completely by 2020, nine years from now. Whether my father makes it to the date is questionable, we can only hope.

Three More Prescriptions

Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

He sits straight in the chair, his hands clasped in front of himself, his elbows resting on the chair’s armrests. The wife confides that she’s quite alarmed by the change in her spouse over the last two and a half months. They are an attractive couple, tall and handsome with dark hair. To look at the spouse there appears to be nothing wrong. Only when the physician asks the patient to perform a set of three discrete movements with his hand, does it become apparent he is unable to learn three simple gestures. His hands shake, his arms quiver. His face focuses and watches his hand and it’s obvious he is attempting to learn the sequence, but has a lot of trouble.

The patient is not yet sixty and was diagnosed with PD in the last three years. The difficulty he has learning is profound and not typical of the standard patient with the illness. Though cognitive function is affected in Parkinson’s disease, it is more likely to occur later, after ten years, or more. The process is gradual and begins with general slowing of thought. Patients with PD retain the ability to learn, though it may take them longer.

The pramipexole the patient takes contributes to his muddied mind. The dosage is escalating and with it the patient is more paranoid, more anxious, more forgetful and more preoccupied with sex. The spouse relates her husband may set a glass of water down and then not find it. He is unable to fix simple things like the towel flapper and doesn’t attempt to fix the computer any more. He got in the car and drove through his neighborhood lost.

The physician would like the patient to undergo neuropsychological testing. The pattern of his cognitive deficits may point to whether the patient suffers from Lewy Body Disease, Alzheimer’s or other dementia. He recommends the patient begin taking Namenda, Exelon or Aricept to slow the process of mental decline. Seroquel he recommends for sleeping, with instructions that the patient up the dose until he arrives at a dose that will allow him to sleep 6 hours without interruption.

The cost of Seroquel has been prohibitive. The patient is completely disabled and the spouse works to pay the bills. Three more medications are not what she hoped for. The doctor gives her several sheets of paper, commenting they may qualify to receive drugs free. The wife thinks not, her salary is not paltry but goes completely to pay their financial obligations.

The Vet

Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

When the physician saw him five months ago, the patient was worried about his cognitive function and being able to work fulltime as a veterinarian. Today he’s concerned about his right hand. He makes more errors when typing and his handwriting has become increasingly smaller and cramped. The doctor comments patients sometimes complain of sensory changes in their hands but to him tingling and numbness sounds more like carpal tunnel syndrome than Parkinson’s disease. He offers to have the patient referred for sensory evaluation, if he thinks it is a serious problem.

He no longer works fulltime, but substitutes for others when they go on vacation. He finds the days where he was able to fill clinical rooms with patients, and go between rooms easily, have passed. He now finds he must concentrate on the animal on the examination table, and see clients one at a time. Though he has paid his insurance company for more than thirty years he is having a difficult time getting them to compensate him for the disability he has. The physician assures him that when they eventually acquire his medical records, they will see in the notes that he has trouble with frontal lobe functions; in planning and executing sequential tasks. From the viewpoint of pet owner, one hopes that more than thirty years of work in his field has given him a foundation of knowledge that will not be easily swept away.

Assessing his physical symptoms, the doctor notes the muscles surrounding the wrist and elbow are loose and supple, and that he clearly is benefiting from his medications. The patient confides when he skips a dose during the day he gets a dystonic cramp in his foot during the night. Reviewing medications, the patient notes Azilect, an MAO-B inhibitor has risen in cost to twelve dollars per pill. The medication potentiates the effect of Sinemet. As a coincidence, the drug representative has just left an arm load of samples on the physician’s desk. The doctor breaks the cellophane tape from the turquoise boxes and gives the patient half of the samples.

Prior to the patient’s arrival the drug rep. spent several minutes enlightening the physician that the blackbox warnings Azilect used to carry have been determined to be unfounded, and are no longer listed as potential problems.

In the past, the black box warning stated that “Azilect at any dose may be associated with a hypertensive crisis/“cheese reaction” if the patient ingests tyramine-rich foods, beverages, or dietary supplements or amines (from over-the-counter medications). Hypertensive crisis, which in some cases may be fatal, consists of marked systemic blood pressure elevation and requires immediate treatment/hospitalization”. However, this adverse effect has been shown to be extremely unlikely when patients use the low doses recommended for slowing progression of PD or to improve the effects of levodopa/carbidopa.

The doctor has also prescribed the dopamine agonist pramipexole (Mirapex) because the medication acts whether or not the patient has a meal that is high in protein. Lastly, the doctor emphasizes the patient would benefit from regular cardiovascular exercise and stretching. The patient notes he has just renewed his gym membership.


Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

The patient suffers from akathisia, an unbearable feeling of inner restlessness that manifests in movement. Whether the person shuffles the feet back and forth, or repeatedly rises and sits from the chair or paces in place, remaining immobile is nearly impossible. The symptoms may arise as a side effect of medications. Neuroleptic antipsychotics (the major tranquilizers) especially the phenothiazines, thioxanthenes, butyrophenones, piperazines, antiemetics and stimulants are known to bring about the problem. People with Parkinson’s disease, and Huntington’s disease may suffer with the condition.

The patient describes rage, feeling like he must fight against the world. He doesn’t want to meet people for lunch, go for a walk, leave the house or exercise. He feels he constantly maintains equilibrium by practicing anger management. He gets no relief, and he states he’s worn down by the constant agitation, anxiety and feeling of coldness. Whatever the physician has tried is not working. He needs a new solution as fast as possible.

The doctor recommends Seroquel at night to calm him down and to improve sleep and to maintain it for at least six hours, straight. When the patient finds he is sleeping six hours, then he is taking the correct amount, until then he should gradually increase the medication. He also recommends taking it in smaller doses, during the day, working up to taking it four times, spread throughout daylight hours.

After changing the state of the patient’s akathisia, he would like the patient to schedule his days with an assortment of activities. Getting out of the house, getting exercise and meeting others should be included in a weekly agenda. Until the patient reaps some benefit from Seroquel, he is likely to be at risk of suicide. The nurse coordinator speaks separately with the spouse of the patient, encouraging her to be the one who controls access to medications. The patient stands heads above the physician and his spouse. Northern European, perhaps Norwegian Viking genes have endowed the patient with the height and strength to inflict serious bodily injury on someone, should he become upset. His teary wife is not the only one hoping for a quick change in circumstances.

The muscles of your jawbone go berserk, so that you bite the inside of your mouth and your jaw locks and the pain throbs. For hours every day this will occur. Your spinal column stiffens so that you can hardly move your head or your neck and sometimes your back bends like a bow and you cannot stand up. The pain grinds into your fiber … You ache with restlessness, so you feel you have to walk, to pace. And then as soon as you start pacing, the opposite occurs to you; you must sit and rest. Back and forth, up and down you go in pain you cannot locate, in such wretched anxiety you are overwhelmed, because you cannot get relief even in breathing. Jack Henry Abbot, In the Belly of the Beast (1981/1991).

Golden Slippers

Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

The dyskinesias keep her moving while she sits in the wheelchair. She comments on the heat, and I mention she has the ocean breeze on the east coast, which we lack. Her live-in assistant wheels her through the hallway. They are off to explore a nursery in Plant City. As we speak I imagine how this would be, holding a conversation while randomly moving your body. I concentrate on the content of her words, because her face moves away. She is accustomed to it, having had dyskinesias for many years, but perhaps it disturbs her, still.

We are wearing the same shoes. Hers are fancier, being glittery gold. She had identical ones to mine, but lost her left one while walking on the beach. A wave came, ran over her feet and sucked her shoe off, taking it into the surf before she had the wits to go after it. She bought the glittery pair in Sarasota at a swank shoe store, for twice as much money.

With dyskinesia, and sitting in the clinic’s wheelchair, she is still a cheery person. The superficial veins on the top side of her feet are so numerous they give her feet and ankles a bluish cast. Her face is beautiful and marked by age and the sun. She wears her long hair in a pony tail.

To improve her sleep, she has found a single tablet of diphenhydramine, the ingredient in Benadryl, helps her to fall asleep. The doctor comments she may find she sleeps the whole night through, if she takes two. She is one who would benefit from the partial dopamine agonist Pardoprunox, which recently completed stage three clinical trials. Whether the FDA will allow the product to come to patient’s hands, and how long they will take to make the decision is anyone’s guess. The drug has been in testing for the last five years. In the meantime, the doctor recommends amantadine, three times a day at 100 mg. Given early in the process of the disease it may provide some protective and slowing affect. In later stages of the illness it can give some patients a therapeutic window without daily dyskinesias.

The Cochran Review states, “There is not enough evidence about the safety and effectiveness of amantadine for people with dyskinesia in Parkinson’s disease.” Though a physician might not routinely recommend the medication, when a patient sits in front of you complaining of obvious debilitating dyskinesia, any relief is helpful. A study of PD patients with severe dyskinesia found those given amantadine were significantly improved over baseline at days 15 and 30 of the investigation. Over the next seven months the average dyskinesia score returned to baseline for all those given the drug. After withdrawal of the medication two patients experienced episodes of severe body heat, which ceased with reintroduction of the drug, and a slower more gradual withdrawal. Side effects of the medication include confusion, hallucinations, tachycardia, and swelling of the feet. Such fallout is similar to all anti-parkinson drugs, and the doctor states it is actually one of the more benign drugs.

The Star Patient

Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

It may be the color of her shirt, a cool placid blue, she appears serene as she settles in the chair. With pearly white thick hair and blue eyes, she holds a brown bottle in her hand. The doctor is speaking, reading the notes from the last office visit, six months ago. He reviews for the medical student, an pretty Indian-looking woman, with long dark hair and glasses who utters,

“Hmm” at appropriate spaces in the physician’s monologue. He enlightens those in the room; patients not hampered by their symptoms do not take medications, other than drugs that have some preventative value. Coenzyme Q10 is available over the counter, though the pills become expensive when taken at the recommended dose, 1200 mg/day. The patient sits across from the physician, and when he mentions the coenzyme, she declares it has been effective for her. She began taking the pills three years ago when she was first diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease. Rather than buy them from the neighborhood health food shop she buys her coenzyme online, from Willner Chemists, in New York City. Sometimes the company has sizable discounts. Also important, the 400 mg dose pills she takes is large and soft, so it slides down the throat easily.

At last the doctor asks, how is she? She is very well. How rare. Her face glows and she smiles and speaks about her life. She enjoys tutoring children, she does Tai Chi, plays ping-pong, has a stationary bike she uses daily. Her painting and calligraphy classes begin soon. She eats well. Sleep is tricky. Her spouse snores. When she is eating well she sleeps deeply. Since diagnosis though she has gained twenty pounds. Her closet is home to size eight clothes and she would like to weigh less, which means sleeping may become more of an issue.

The doctor states three years from diagnosis, the average patient’s symptoms have become bilateral. On physical examination the muscles surrounding her left wrist are supple and loose. While speaking the doctor catches a glimpse of the tremor in the patient’s right hand. The patient claims she can attenuate the tremor when it begins. In his book about Parkinson’s disease, Michael J. Fox talks about when he lost the ability to quell the tremor in his hand.

The patient remarks her advice to those with the illness,

“Tell nobody.” Her family is unaware of her diagnosis and they went on vacation together. Only her spouse knows about her illness. Before leaving she asks whether there is anything else she might do to keep the disease at bay. It seems she is doing everything she can, even her attitude is light. About exercising, the doctor recommends getting her heart rate up to eighty percent of her maximum, for her age, and keeping it there, for an increasing number of minutes, at least three times a week.

Driving Privilege

Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

The physician asked him to undergo a driving evaluation. Performed by an occupational therapist, the pre-road evaluation checks mobility, reaction times and coordination. They assess the ability to move the foot from the accelerator and brake pedal while maintaining the hands on the steering wheel. Cognition, memory, judgment, attention, self-awareness and perception are recorded to determine if these areas have an impact on driving. The paper he received from the woman told him he had failed and his driving skills were sub-standard. He has distinct feelings about this woman, and reports his eyes are better than they were six months ago.

From section 322.126 (2), (3) the Florida state government mandates that “Any physician, person, or agency having knowledge of any licensed driver’s or applicant’s mental or physical disability to drive…is authorized to report such knowledge to the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles… The reports authorized by this section shall be confidential… No civil or criminal action may be brought against any physician, person or agency who provides the information herein.”

Once the paperwork is submitted it is screened and forwarded to investigators who work for the division of motor vehicles. They contact the driver and submit their findings to the medical review section in Tallahassee. Investigators may interview family members, neighbors, or the driver’s physician as part of the investigation. As a result, drivers may be requested to submit a medical report from their physician, or they may be required to report to a driver license office for re-testing. If the investigator does not find any substance or validity to the complaint, no further action is taken.

The American Medical Association urges physicians to consult patients and their families about voluntarily giving up the ability to drive, and the risks they take when they continue driving. Changing driving habits and limiting driving may help. If the person steadfastly refuses to give up driving, when proven to be unsafe, physicians are urged to report their patient to the Department of Motor Vehicles, after telling them they are required to do so. The AMA states it is the duty and obligation of the doctor, to report unsafe drivers.

In Oregon, any answer of, Yes to the following three questions will result in the withdrawal of driving privileges:

1. Do you have a vision condition or impairment that has not been corrected by glasses, contacts or surgery that affects your ability to drive safely?

2. Do you have any physical or mental conditions or impairments that affect your ability to drive safely?

3. Do you use alcohol, inhalants, or controlled substances to a degree that affects your ability to drive safely?

In Oregon, the state law mandates that the primary care provider must report an unsafe driver to the DMV. The office evaluates each mandatory report and if certain criteria are met, the person’s driver license is suspended. The individual receives a Notice of Suspension in the mail, and their license suspension takes effect 5 days from the date on the notice.

Families may agonize about how to wrestle the car keys from their loved one. There are safe guards in place that protect the public from unsafe drivers, we can only hope the primary care physicians act on their duty and obligation.

Eighteen Years

Posted by & filed under Weekly Journal.

For eighteen years she’s had PD, and she’s been seeing the doctor since she was first diagnosed. She had been married then, living in the Keys with her spouse where they owned a restaurant. That was some time ago and now she lives on the east coast of the state and makes the three hour journey with a friend who drives. They have a birthday party to attend later in the day. She uses a rolling three- wheeled walker when she walks. It has a large pocket where she stashes all the things she might need.

She mentions when she was a child she used to be claustrophobic. She had to sit in the passenger seat in the front of the car, because sitting in the middle, or in the very back of the car made her feel as though she can’t breathe. She was the youngest and smallest child in the family and yet she was relegated to the seat in front. She still gets the sensation these days, and feels it may be worsening. The doctor states Parkinson’s disease probably has little to do with the feeling. She stands and paces in the small room, then sits back down. Her blood pressure is quite high today. The systolic a bit over 170. The doctor checks her past pressures and notes they have become progressively higher over time. He urges her to take her pressure regularly, and to make sure her general physician is aware of her numbers.

Without dyskinesia, she has occasional tremor in both hands. It doesn’t stop her from activities. She played bingo the previous evening. Her symptoms are well controlled with morning Parcopa, the dissolvable form of Sinemet, and the Neupro patch. She gets the original formulation, flown in from England monthly and kept on ice until it gets to her door. She keeps the medication in the refrigerator. Every month she pays five hundred dollars. She concedes it took two months to get her medications under control when she began using the patch. She was not able to immediately cut the intake of Sinemet, but she’s become accustomed to it.

The autonomic signs of the illness appear in flashes of sweating, somewhat akin to what menopausal women experience. She knows to eat fiber rich food, for her bowels. Her frequent urination was diagnosed previously. She claims the issue doesn’t bother her. Her voice lacks the breathy quality many patients with the disease acquire.

The doctor would like to add a mild antidepressant to her regimen of medications. It will also improve her sleep quality, as she is unable to take Seroquel without feeling as though she has been completely anesthetized. She claims to be able to feel her medication begin taking affect in her body. The sensation begins in the toes and works upwards, as though a current, covering her entire body. Other times she will feel her muscles suddenly slacken from the constant tension that keeps them rigid.


Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)


Your Question